I can't contain my thoughts on this week any longer. Neil Diamond songs??? Kill me. Weak theme, if you ask me. Here's my rundown of the performances:Syesha-1st song "Hello" was too old-fashioned and cheesy. Yet I can't deny she has a really good voice. 2nd song was MUCH better. I like her when she does the more "broadway/theatrical-type" songs. I think that is her strong suit.
David A-I know people love this kid, but I just think he's not for me. He kind of would work as a Josh Groban type or something. He seems a bit awkward on stage. The "Coming to America" song was kind of weird.
David Cook-I am not normally a "rock" music fan, but I have to say I think he's the most talented "up to date" singer on the show this year. He tends to take even a Neil Diamond song and make it sound somewhat remotely cool. Now that is a talent. I wasn't really crazy about either song he sang, but I thought he did much better than the others.
Jason-this kid is so laid back and sort of reminds me of that James Taylor vibe. He could be cool. But each time he sings it is the SAME SAME SAME.
Brooke-Oh my dear thing. That song "I'm a Believer" was so cheesy. Simon called it a "nightmare." I felt bad for her. She seems like such a nice person. I was sorry she got voted off tonight. Probably bc of Simon's comment. People tend to vote along with him. I thought she did good on her 2nd song "I am, I said." But I guess it wasn't good enough to keep her in. And I was really rooting for her, too. Shoot.
David Cook-I am not normally a "rock" music fan, but I have to say I think he's the most talented "up to date" singer on the show this year. He tends to take even a Neil Diamond song and make it sound somewhat remotely cool. Now that is a talent. I wasn't really crazy about either song he sang, but I thought he did much better than the others.
Jason-this kid is so laid back and sort of reminds me of that James Taylor vibe. He could be cool. But each time he sings it is the SAME SAME SAME.
Brooke-Oh my dear thing. That song "I'm a Believer" was so cheesy. Simon called it a "nightmare." I felt bad for her. She seems like such a nice person. I was sorry she got voted off tonight. Probably bc of Simon's comment. People tend to vote along with him. I thought she did good on her 2nd song "I am, I said." But I guess it wasn't good enough to keep her in. And I was really rooting for her, too. Shoot.
4 comments:
hey amiee- you've been tagged again! on a similar tagging- go to my blog for the instructions :)
I pretty much agree with all your AI comments, sad to see Brooke go I hoping at least she would be top 3. I thnk the 'I'm a believer' song sent her home, it was painful to listen to, so not her chilled out song style. I think David C will take home the title this year, but he deserves it I look forward to his performances each week. I like David A but don't care for the songs he sings. Youre right about Jason c, same ol same ol, I picture him on a beach somewhere singing those types of songs.
BTW I love all the picts of Jase in LA, the one of him sleeping on the plane is adorable.
Amen to all your AI thoughts. I think it was time for Brooke to go, though. She's not really that great of a vocalist - but her style is awesome. Same with Jason. Anyway, I just looked at all your LA pics - how cool! I especially love the ones of Jase. What a cutie. And how fun for you guys to see so many friends and family!
you are so hilarious. I'm SOOOOOO glad I'm not hooked on idol this year. I haven't even watched 1 episode.
Post a Comment